5 Pros of Accepting a Counteroffer: How to Know if It’s Right for You

Pros of accepting a counteroffer

Share This Post

Leaving your current job for a new job opening at a different company can be a tough decision, especially if you receive a counteroffer from your current company.

A counteroffer is an offer made by your current employer in response to another offer you have accepted from another company. It can be tempting to accept a counteroffer, but there are several factors you should consider before making a decision. In this blog post, we will discuss the five pros of accepting a counteroffer and how to know if it’s right for you!

Remain in a Similar Work Environment

When you accept a counteroffer, you can stay in your current job. This means you won’t have to adapt to a new work setting, new co-workers, or new management personnel all at once.

Depending on how long you have been at your current company, you may not want to leave all the amazing people you have worked with over the past few years. You’ll also get to keep other elements of your job that you may have become familiar with, including your daily commute, work environment, benefits, and much more.

However, if you are leaving mainly due to the commute, work environment, or benefits, then it may be in your best interest to decline the counteroffer.

Gaining an Improved Sense of Self-Worth

Professionalism is very important in the workplace. That is why employers place a high value on employees with a sense of self-worth. When an employer makes a counteroffer to an employee, it is usually because they don’t want to lose that employee. That feeling of being appreciated and valued by the company will make any employee feel amazing. This can introduce a sense of self-worth into the employee’s professional life.

Additionally, only 21% of CFOs extend counteroffers to keep employees from leaving. That means if you have received a counteroffer, chances are your employer appreciates you.

When an employer makes a counteroffer, it is usually a sign that they value their employees and are willing to invest in them. This can be a very positive experience for both the employer and the employee. In some cases, the employee may even gain a new appreciation for the company.

Percentage of CFOs That Dont Extend Counteroffers

Avoiding Additional Training

One of the benefits of staying in your current role is that you don’t have to go through the training process for a new position. This can be a big relief, especially if you feel like you have already mastered your current position.

Training takes time and energy, and adjusting to a new work environment can be challenging. If you’re happy with your current position, there’s no need to put yourself through that process. You can stay where you are and continue to do your job well. Additionally, if you need some training to fulfill more responsibilities that come with a pay increase, you can still feel comfortable completing your training. You’re already familiar with the company’s mission and values, so you won’t have to adapt to a new environment. All things considered, it’s often best to stay in your current role instead of making a move to a new company.

Earning a Higher Salary

One of the most obvious benefits of accepting a counteroffer is earning a higher salary. If you’re content with your current position and feel you have more to give to the company, then negotiating a higher salary is a no-brainer. You don’t have to go through the hiring process to earn more money. You may even perform the same duties for more money, making your time more valuable.

In addition, accepting a counteroffer allows you to negotiate other terms of your employment, such as vacation time, flexible hours, or telecommuting options. If you’re unhappy with your current situation, then a counteroffer may be just what you need to stay with the company and continue earning a good salary.

Just remember, you do not need to apply to other job openings to get a higher salary. There are ways to ask for a raise without having to rely on a counteroffer.

Increased Productivity

A counteroffer can motivate you to maintain high productivity levels and exceed your employer’s standards. After being presented with a counteroffer, you may feel like it’s your chance to prove yourself to your employer. Feeling appreciated by your company can lead to increased satisfaction in your work.

If you’re given the opportunity to earn more money, you may also feel like you have more to lose if you don’t meet expectations. As a result, accepting a counteroffer can be a great way to motivate yourself to stay focused and produce high-quality work.

Now that you know the pros of accepting a counteroffer, it is crucial to know that there are cons to accepting a counteroffer as well. If you are considering accepting a counteroffer, remember to consider the following before doing so:

  • An issue is not resolved with a counteroffer
  • There is no career progression
  • Your employer will question loyalty after a counteroffer
  • It will not guarantee job satisfaction
  • Your employer may be worried that you are going to look elsewhere for jobs in the future

Remember that every situation is different when deciding whether or not to accept a counteroffer. Consider all of the above before making the tough decision to stay with your current employer!

Subscribe & Follow

Gain a competitive advantage with our free 2025 Salary Guide

Access our Salary Guide with over 300+ detailed salary breakdowns for roles in Rhode Island!

Illustration of a woman sitting at a desk, analyzing data on two floating screens. One screen displays a pie chart, while the other shows a rising bar graph. The woman is smiling and gesturing towards the visuals. The desk has financial documents, a calculator, and a roll of paper. The illustration is grayscale with green highlights on key elements.

More To Explore

Promotional blog post image titled “How to Use AI to Automate Job Applications,” featuring a pair of illustrated robotic hands typing on a green laptop. The text highlights AI's role in helping job seekers craft resumes, write cover letters, and speed up applications, with a call-to-action button labeled “Learn More” and the URL citypersonnel.net.

How to Use AI to Automate Job Applications Without Getting Caught

As artificial intelligence becomes more integrated into everyday workflows, job seekers are increasingly turning to AI tools to help craft …

Read More →
Promotional graphic for a blog post titled “What to Do When an Employer Asks for Your Salary History.” A smiling woman in a black blazer holds a fan of hundred-dollar bills. The text encourages readers to learn how to navigate salary history questions with confidence and strategy. A “Learn More” button and the website URL citypersonnel.net are displayed.

What to Do When an Employer Asks for Your Salary History (And You Don’t Want to Give It)

You’ve made it to the interview stage, the conversation is going well—and then it happens. “Can you tell us about …

Read More →
A promotional graphic for a blog post titled "The Psychology Behind Why People Fail Interviews (And How to Avoid It)". It features a man in glasses and a wrinkled dress shirt wiping his forehead with a tissue, looking nervous. A "Learn More" button and a website URL are included.

The Psychology Behind Why People Fail Interviews (And How to Avoid It)

Job interviews can be nerve-wracking experiences, with high stakes that can determine the next step in your career. Despite being …

Read More →